Top 31 Shows of 2015 (Part 1)

2015 ushered in the idea of Peak TV in america.  With 409 scripted shows airing within the year, it was simultaneously impossible to watch everything and to be left with nothing to watch.  I set out to do a top 20, and wasn't able to.  I figured I would compromise and do a top 25, but still could not narrow my list down.  Even when i gave myself 30 as a magic number, I still had to cheat and make it 31.  So here you have it, my top 31 shows of 2015.

(Disclaimer:  There is no way I watched all 409 shows.  There will be shows on here that you like that I don't like or that I haven't seen.  Get over it.  I'm talking to you, Game Of Thrones fans.)

31. Man Seeking Woman 

 FX (new show)

Something about Jay Baruchel has always appealed to me.  The mix of his every-man appearance with his comedic delivery and timing suits the FX brand well.  This show had a decent amount of misses, but when it hit, it was gold.

30.  The Last Man on Earth 

FOX (new show)

The Last Man on Earth aired its entire first season and half of its second season this year.  The first 3 episodes of this show were some of the best on TV last season.  The rest of season 1 really struggled to make us care about anyone on the show.  Season 2 however, was finally able to make us care about various people on the show, which gave it heart in addition to laughs.  The fall finale is one of the most intense half hours you can watch this season, and certainly blurs the lines between drama and comedy.

29. The Grinder 

FOX (new show)

In The Grinder, Fox has itself the most purely funny show on network television.  The laughs are heavy and often and the 2 part fall finale was some of the funniest stuff I have seen from a network in a long time.  While Rob Lowe is predictably fantastic as the titular Grinder (the name Mitchard Grinder will never not be funny) Fred Savage does the real heavy lifting in his very triumphant return to life in front of the camera

28.  Red Oaks 

AMAZON (new show)

Red Oaks was really lost in the streaming shuffle.  This look at life in 80’s at a suburban country club is so earnest and funny that it really deserves to get more eyes on it.  Kudos to David Gordon Green and Amy Heckerling for giving us an amazing tribute to 80's body swapping in the shows 7^th episode.

27. The League 

FXX (not ranked)

Going into its final season, The League was a proven commodity that was always good for a laugh.  The final season saw Nick Kroll return to an almost full schedule and the show was much better off for it.  While never one of the best shows on TV, The League will be missed for its wild jokes and for the chemistry its cast of mostly stand up and improv comedians has.

26. Orange is the New Black

NETFLIX (#3)

I Really didn’t think this show could fall this far on my list, but the 3^rd season just didn’t do it for me as much as the first 2, and during Peak TV in America, that’s enough to drag the show down to 26.  The religious arc of the season was a brave attempt, and while it succeeded on many fronts, it made certain episodes drag, and thus the season did not seem to flow as well as the first two for me.  Nonetheless, it was still a very solid season of TV and I anxiously await the 4^th season.

25. Inside Amy Schumer 

COMEDY CENTRAL (not ranked)

Amy Schumer had one of the best years a comedian has ever had, and her Comedy Central show reached some new heights this year.  12 Angry Men Inside Amy Schumer was one of the best half hours of TV this season.  Hopefully her new found success does not cut this show short.

24. Brooklyn 99 

FOX (11)

Brooklyn 99 has a very solid formula going for it in its 3^rd season.  The cast, which really is an embarrassment of riches at this point, all do their respective shticks well and the show is always good for at least a couple belly laughs every episode.  Unfortunately, it suffers from being on network TV and having to produce so many episodes every season, thus the slide down my rankings.

23. South Park 

COMEDY CENTRAL (not ranked)

 South Park is one of those shows that I’m always glad is around, but don’t often go out of my way to watch unless I hear about an especially good episode.  In its 19^th (wow!) season though, South Park presented a serialized story of gentrification and PC society, and boy was it fantastic.  The serialized nature  gave new life to the show and hopefully something that Stone and Parker keep doing going forward

22. Wet Hot American Summer: 1^st Day of Camp 

NETFLIX (new show)

With what the cast of the WHAS movie has accomplished since the films released, it is a minor miracle that this was made.  To go along with that, with all the principals returning for this Netflix series, there was really a high floor and an even higher ceiling for this show.  The mini-series, set entirely on the first day of camp, did a great job of servicing its old cast members with the humor we have come to expect from The State and integrating new actors into the world of camp Firewood. If nothing else, at least we finally know how H. Jon Benjamin turned into a can of peas.

21. Last Week Tonight With John Oliver 

HBO (10)

DUDE FLEW TO RUSSIA TO INTERVIEW EDWARD SNOWDEN! Do I need to say more?  That John Oliver has become my go to source for current event commentary and skewering in a mere 2 seasons says enough about how fantastic this show is.  Comedy Central really let a gem get away when they allowed Oliver to sign with HBO, and were probably really kicking themselves when looking for a replacement for Jon Stewart this year.

20. Fresh off The Boat 

ABC (new show)

Diversity in a network comedy?! Who would have thought!  This show, along with Blackish and Empire represented a banner year for diverse programming on network TV and in my opinion; this was the best of the bunch.  The humor is not derived from the fact that these characters are Asian American living in a predominantly white world, but instead is derived from fantastic writing that lends itself well to the fantastic performances.  Constance Wu is the real break out star here.  Shaq-Fu really is the comedic gift that never stops giving.

19. Nathan For You 

COMEDY CENTRAL (not ranked)

Comedy Central’s faux business makeover show hit highs that it had not in the years passed.  As the season went on, the lines between reality and parody were further blurred as we dove deeper inside the psyche of Nathan Fielder the character, and as the season progressed, the work of Nathan Fielder the actor/comedian really took off.

18. UnReal 

LIFETIME (New Show)

A TV show airing on Lifetime has made my rankings.  That is the definition of Peak TV.  This dramatic skewering of the bachelor and reality TV in general was sharp, dramatic, and funny all at once.  The two female leads (Shiri Appleby and Constance Zimmer), both do a fantastic job as producers who not only give up their lives, but their souls in order to put on a successful show

17. Veep 

HBO (22)

Veep, in perhaps its funniest season, really spread the wealth his year.  Aside from being able to service its large cast, the show was able to really provide stand out moments for Anna Chlumsky and integrate new comer Hugh Laurie seamlessly.  The show is just chugging along in its 5^th season and should continue to dominate at the Emmy’s for the duration of its run

16. Louie 

FX (13)

People really take this show for granted at this point.  I’m probably guilty of it too.  But this show in its 5^th season continues to be hilarious and to push the boundaries of what actually qualifies as a comedy.  One week the show can be about a hilarious sexual experience, and the next it can be about horrifying nightmares.  This season also featured the single best guest performance in any show t, giving us a side of Michael Rappaport I did not think existed.

Review: Galavant (ABC)

"Actually, I don't know. I've been thinking a lot about it every since he kidnapped me, and I'm gonna go with the fame and fortune"

Dan Fogelman's last show to air on ABC had one of the worst pilots I had ever seen.  "The Neighbors" was a one joke premise and that joke involved aliens having the same names as famous athletes.  I very quickly dismissed the show as just another piece of pilot season garbage.  The show ended up running for a couple of seasons on ABC Fridays and actually did provide two bright spots in the form of two very entertaining musical episodes.  So when Fogelman's new show, Galavant, was announced as a musical comedy set in the middle ages, I was definitely intrigued enough to give the show a shot.

Galavant tells the story of a knight, the titular Galavant, and his quest to get the woman he loves back from the evil king.  This all sounds like fairly standard stuff until its revealed that the woman he loves actually chose to stay with the king, sacrificing love for a life of riches and fame.  This choice causes Galavant to live in a drunken stupor, until a princess from a land invaded by the evil king comes to ask for his help, and he sees it as a chance to win back the woman he fell in love with.

The meat of Galavant is the musical aspect of it.  The songs are rather catchy, but really that has more to do with their repetitive nature than their cleverness.  Throughout the first episode (ABC will be airing two every night for four weeks) the same song is sang over and over.  The 2nd episode that aired had the better music and on the whole was actually more entertaining than the first.

The real standout performance here is by Timothy Omundson as King Richard.  He seems to be having so much fun as the evil king who really may just be misunderstood.  Vinnie Jones plays his bodyguard Gareth and is also quiet a treat.  The only other performance that stands out so far is Luke Youngblood (who some may know as Magnitude on Community, Pop Pop!) as Galavant's faithful squire and only friend.

All in all Galavant is.... an OK show.  Its fun and harmless without ever actually being all that funny.  The setting and musical aspect has allowed the show to net some interesting guest stars which i will be curious to see over the next few weeks.  By burning out all the episodes in one month, ABC obviously doesn't see Galavant as a match for anything else on the network and probably doesn't see it in it's long term plans (despite debuting to some fairly decent ratings).  I'll stick with it for the time being just for its uniqueness and brevity of its run .

GALAVANT (ABC):  6 OUT OF 10

Top 25 TV Shows of 2014 (Part 2)

Numbers 25-16 (  Which can be seen HERE )  on my list were some shows i really loved, which should speak volumes of what i think these next shows.

If you couldn't find something to watch on TV in 2014, then you really just weren't trying hard enough.  This easily the deepest year in television programming in my memory, and this list could have easily been a top 50.  With new entries from the likes of Amazon, Netflix and Comedy Central, 2014 was not only the deepest year of programming, but perhaps the most diverse as well.  Without further ado...

15.  The Affair (Showtime)

Showtime's drama about 2 married people having an affair with each other during one summer is so much more than that.  By using a Rashoman style of story telling, we get to see just how funny and fragile a thing the human memory is.  Be it outfits, order of events, oer even whole conversations, its quite amazing how two people can experience the same events  but remember aspects about them completely differently.  Complete with an absolutely fantastic cast led by Dominic West and Ruth Wilson, The Affair is a captivating and often fully engrossing experience.



14.  Hannibal (NBC)

The fact that Hannibal is a thing that will now be occurring for 3 seasons on a broadcast network really astonishes me.  It is so violent and at times so disturbing that i think it would be a hard sell on HBO or Showtime, let alone NBC.  But whatever grace of god has given us Hannibal, hopefully it doesn't go away anytime soon.  Hannibal is the most beautiful looking show on TV.  It may sound morbid to say that about a show where violent murders and cannibalism happen on the regular, but the cinematography of this show is a cut above any other show.  The storytelling was spot on in season 2, whether dealing with Will Graham in jail, or dealing with the titular doctors murderous tendencies.



13.  Louie (FX)

Louis CK took a year off from making episodes in 2013, partly to avoid getting burned out and apparently partly to reinvent himself.  Louie was never a traditional sitcom, opting to forgo continuity to build episodes and vignettes as mini-movies.  Such episodes were still present in season 4 ( So Did The Fat Lady and Back/Model are 2 very good episodes) but they were the exception.  Louie gave us a 6 part story of romancing a foreigner, a 3 part story of his relationship with Pamela and a 90 minute episode that CK was barely in.  A lot of it worked really well, and while I may not have enjoyed this season as much as the first 3,  I will always appreciate a show taking risks, and I will always appreciate having Louie on the air.



12.  Broad City (Comedy Central)

If it feels like the 2 actresses at the center of Broad City have the chemistry of people who have worked together forever, it's because they really have.  Co-creators Ilana Glazer and Abbi Jacobson had two years to let their street smart, quirky comedic timing and chemistry grow.  Whats so refreshing about Broad City is that it doesn't try to be something bigger than what it is, 2 slacker friends living their lives and owning everything they do.  The fact that it makes you crack up every 2 minutes only helps you realize that you are watching what could become the female comedic voices of our future.



11.  Brooklyn 99 (FOX)

In it's 2nd half of season one and the 1st half of season 2, Brooklyn 99 was able to grab the throne of the most purely funny show on network TV.  It's no surprise that a show coming from Parks and Recreation veteran Mike Schur was really able to find itself after a rocky start with a very solid cast.  Andre Braugher should be nominated for every supporting actor award that exists for his deadpan portrayal of Captain Holt.  All the supporting players are fantastic.  The show also gets major props for finally finding a successful way to utilize the always hilarious Joe Lo Truglio.  Even Andy Samberg, who might have been the weakest part of the show when it first began, has turned into a very solid lead.  With Parks and Recreation signing off this year, here's hoping that B99 has a nice lengthy run in its place.



10.  Last Week Tonight with John Oliver (HBO)

I covered this show extensively a few weeks ago HERE


9.  Sons Of Anarchy (FX)

This was the most fluid show in my rankings.  At one point I had it at number 7.  At another point in the season I had it at 15.  I ultimately settled it here at number 9 because of a surprisingly subtle (for Kurt Sutter standards) and weirdly beautiful finale.  The Final Ride, as the last season of Sons of Anarchy was called, had its bumps but in the end I didn't care.  I loved every bloated episode for one reason or another.  Sure, many characters were passed redemption, including Jax who was always the audiences entry point into this world, but that was kind of the point.  Jax was beyond redemption so instead of even trying to redeem himself, why not go out in a blaze, and at the same time, try to help everyone else we've grown to love along the way.  Bonus points for one of the most touching scenes of love declaration between Tig and his transgendered girlfriend.


8.  Parks and Recreation (NBC)

Parks and Recreation has been so good for so long, that I think its at a point where many people take it for granted, myself included.  This is the lowest that Parks and Rec has even been on my year end list, but it by no means had a bad season.  Things were put into motion for the upcoming final season, but the penultimate season provided a lot of closure as well.  The episodes leading up to the departure of Rashida Jones and Rob Lowe, as long as the episodes immediately after, were truly fantastic displays of mixing comedy with heart and emotion.  As Parks is apt to do, it absolutely nailed the finale, one that involved a time jump rarely seen on network sitcoms.  This group of government employees have become a family to everyone that has watched them over the years, and this last season is going to be one hell of an emotional roller coaster.



7. Transparent (Amazon)

Finally a solid depiction of a Jewish family!  Sure MOST Jewish families are not dealing with a father figure who is transgendered, but above all else, Transparent is about family and the influences parents have on their children's behavior.  The series is superbly acted and marks a big step forward for Amazon in the scripted programming department.  Often times this show could be laugh out loud funny, only to be completely heartbreaking just minutes later.  Melora Hardin is fantastic and almost unrecognizable as Tammy.  The show also managed to do something in it's flashback episode that few shows do successfully, and that's cast young actors for flashbacks that can actually act and bring a whole new layer to the story.  Bravo, Amazon, I can't wait to see what else you have for us.



6.  You're The Worst (FXX)

Its Harry Met Sally for the millennial generation!   While that may not be entirely true, You're The Worst came out with guns blazing and turned into a hilarious show that really had much more heart than it had any right to.  There is no stereotypical romantic tension to have to bear through here.  The leads have one of the most graphic sex scenes on non premium cable within the first 5 minutes of the show.  After that, we just get the funny story of how two non-perfect people can have a non-perfect relationship, which for them, IS perfect.  Desmin Borges almost steals the show as a PTSD stricken war vet who goes through a ring of emotions throughout the season.  This show came out of nowhere and quickly turned into a comedic powerhouse, hopefully a sign of more things to come from the comedic offshoot of FX.



5.  Silicon Valley (HBO)

The man behind Office Space gives you.... Office Space in the tech world.  Beyond that, Silicon Valley is also the best cast TV comedy of 2014.  The ensemble of nerds and tech geniuses is a powerhouse, punctuated by perhaps the best supporting comedic performance of the year by Christopher Evan Welch (who sadly passed away as the shows season was coming to an end).  Part satire about the douchiness of the tech industry and part scary truth about the douchiness of the tech industry, Silicon Valley is smart and sophomoric at the same time.  Kudos for to the writing staff for including a 10 minute dick joke that actually makes you laugh for the entire 10 minutes.




4.  Mad Men (AMC)

If Mad Men were given the chance to air its final season in its entirity, I am farily certain it would have been number one this list.  AMC, surely realizing their lack of quality upcoming programming, decided to split the final 14 episodes into two 7 episode mini seasons.  While something more action or intensity based like Breaking Bad may be able to pull that off, Mad Men is all about story telling and the slow burn, which makes seven episodes more difficult.  Alas, Matt Weiner and company were still able to pull off a handful of good episodes, with the last 2 before the hiatus being 2 of the series all time best .  We saw Peggy come full circle in her journey to become the female Don Draper, giving her own version of "the carousel".  We saw Don basically hit rock bottom, rally back professionally, only to once again suffer a setback in his personal life.  We saw the return of kick ass Roger Sterling.  And yes, we saw the last of Bertram Cooper, who upon leaving the show and this world reminded us that indeed, the best things in life are free.



3.  Orange Is The New Black (Netflix)

The Netflix prison dramedy came back for season two with much more anticipation than people had for season 1.  The thought of season 2 being a letdown was a very real possibility given the praise heaped on the show after season 1.  With that in mind, its quite amazing that season 2 not only matched season 1 in terms of quality, it surpassed it.  The show uses all parts of its ensemble so freaking well.  The writers took Morello, nothing more than a funny accent in season 1, and used her to give us one the most heartbreaking stories told anywhere this year.  And who would have thought the biggest moment of the season, would go to Miss Rosa, who was barely an afterthought going into this season.  The show was forced to scale back on Piper stories, and the show and the character were better for it.  Honestly, any person in this cast is deserving of awards recognition, but it is such a joy to see Uzo Aduba getting all sorts of recognition for her often funny, often tear inspiring performance as Crazy Eyes.



2.  Review (Comedy Central)

Comedy Central's wildly successful year is topped off by a show that sat on their shelves for almost 2 years because they didn't see the appeal in it.  Andy Daly has been "that guy" in so many things throughout the years, but i knew him best from various podcast appearances.  I knew the man was wildly funny, but i was not prepared for the crazy experiment that was Review.  Daly plays Forrest MacNeil, a TV host who reviews life experiences such as being a racist and having a best friend.  Its the characters dedication to the TV show that really brings the comedy to a new level.  The show takes such dark turns that you would never think could work in a comedy, but they are so wildly uncomfortable and hilarious that you just can't turn away.  I cant really say more without ruining many of the jokes.  Comedy Central's Review: 5 stars.



1.  Fargo (FX)

I still to this day say that the idea of a Fargo TV show on paper was a horrible idea.  The Cohen brothers might have the most distinctive voice in Hollywood and to put perhaps their best story in the hands of someone else, had disaster written all over it.  Noah Hawley (along with approval from the Cohen's) proved me so wrong.  Fargo was compelling, thrilling, smart, funny, you name it.  Every performance in this beautiful show was top notch, from veterans like Martin Freeman and Billy Bob Thorton, to an absolutely perfect new comer like Allison Tolman.  The story that Fargo told was gripping for every step along the way, and Hawley was able to capture enough of the Cohen's voice, while at the same time adding his own flavor to the story.  This show would have been fine as a one and done mini series, but Fargo will return for a season 2, telling a different story than the one we saw in season one.  The only thing MORE difficult than turning Fargo into a great TV show, is doing a second season that could possibly live up  to the first.  I for one, am wildly excited to see Noah Hawley answer the challenge of topping what was the best TV show of 2014