"I have 3 kids, I've been tired since 2005"
When Julie Bowen won an Emmy for best supporting actress a few weeks back, i was shocked. Not because i don’t think she is a talented actress, but on a show with so many funny characters, Claire Dunphy is usually the straight woman. When she is funny, it’s because she is playing off of the other very funny members of her family. Last night, we see Claire away from her family for the most part, and for the most part the episode did not really work for me. Every storyline seemed very forced, especially hers. The show has fallen into this pattern this year with putting Claire in embarrassing situations and the comedy comes from watching her squirm. The thing is, it’s just not all that funny.
The Phil and Haley storyline seemed like it should have been so much funnier than it was. Sure it had its moments, like Phil attempting to do a cheerleading routine along with the squad, but for the most part, it seemed out of character for Phil to freak out so much. One of the reasons last season’s Good Cop Bad Cop episode was funny because it was Phil playing out of character intentionally. This felt like they were attempting the same thing, but this time it wasn’t part of an inside deal between Phil and Claire, it was just Phil not acting like the Phil that we know
The Manny storyline also felt very forced. I see the comedy in Jay becoming invested in a Spanish soap opera, but again, it just felt very out of place for him. The one saving grace of the episode was the Mitchell and Cam storyline. While i feel like it was a story that we’ve seen before with these two, the 2 actors play off of each other so well that it still seemed fresh to me. I could listen to Eric Stonestreet was nostalgically about pot pies all day.
Not the strongest effort by Modern Family but I feel they were due for a clunker. It’s funny how the episodes that i don’t like always seem to have a very minimal amount of Luke in them.
5 out 10